Pat McAfee Rookie Cards

Do you know that the most expensive Pat McAfee Football Rookie Card (2016 Donruss Pat McAfee Signed Rookie Card #131 PSA 10 Autograph) was sold on eBay in 07/2025 for $1007.99 while the cheapest Rookie Card (2006 Upper Deck AJ Hawk Fleer Futures Rookie Card Packers Ohio State Pat McAfee) changed hands for only $1.50 in 10/2024? The month with the most cards sold (10) was September 2023 with an average selling price of $11.75 for a Football Card of Pat McAfee. Sold items reached their highest average selling price in May 2026 with $278.99 and the month that saw the lowest prices with $3.25 was November 2022. In average, a Rookie Card from Pat McAfee is valued at $12.95.

Affiliate disclosure: When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network

Here's a list of Football Rookie Cards of Pat McAfee that are currently for sale on eBay and some other online shops.

Picture	Item Title	Price	Store
	2008 Pat McAfee NCAA Future Stars Rookie Card #40 West Virginia MINT Graded 10	$36.98
	2015 Topps - All-Pro Pat McAfee #282 Rookie Card Colts WVU Goat	$8.25
	Pat McAfee Colts 2015 Topps Football #282 Only Rookie Card SP RC ESPN WWE	$16.85
	PAT MCAFEE SIGNED 2015 TOPPS AP #282 ROOKIE CARD RC COLTS BECKETT AUTO BGS BAS	$399.99
	PAT MCAFEE SIGNED 2016 DONRUSS ROOKIE CARD RC #131 COLTS BECKETT BAS AUTO	$299.99
	Pat McAfee WWE 2025 Topps Now Thrills WWE Universe with Standout Performance #51 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card	$49.99

To give you a bigger picture, here are some more Football Rookie Cards of Pat McAfee that were sold recently on eBay. In total, we scanned 223 sales to create the statistics about price trends and current value of Pat McAfee Football Rookie Cards shown on top of this page.

Picture	Item Title	Price	Store
	2015 Topps - All-Pro Pat McAfee #282 Rookie Card Colts WVU Goat	$9.99
	2015 Topps Pat McAfee #282 PSA 10 Rookie Card RC	$150.00
	2015 Topps Pat McAfee RC rookie card Colts West Virginia punter WWE ESPN show	$9.99
	2015 Topps PAT MCAFEE Rookie Card BGS 9.5 RC Colts	$119.99
	2022 Panini Instant WWE Pat McAfee #60 RC Summer Rookie Card 1/684 GEM	$115.00
	PAT MCAFEE SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED 2022 PANINI RC ROOKIE CARD WWE PSA DNA SLABBED	$278.99